What Do You Get When You Cross Elm Treason With Classical Music?

Remember those good old “cross with” jokes we used to love as kids?  For example: What do you get when you cross a dessert with a reptile? A pie-thon.  Or how about: What do you get when you cross a karate tournament with swine? Pork chops.  No offense to the ninjas out there. If you could kindly refrain from the death threats that would be grand. And please no hate mail from the pastry chefs out there.

Well, what do you get when you cross Bach, Beethoven and Schubert with Elm Treason?

Some very interesting songs … and that’s no riddle.

I have fond memories of studying classical piano as a child. Later I studied music formally in college.  Andy also had a lot of exposure to classical music — as well as a dozen other genres–  at home.  His favorite composer is Beethoven and mine is JS Bach (with Beethoven at a close second place).  So it would be inevitable that these experiences would filter into our acoustic rock composing.

On our second album “Acoustic Treason,” the first guitar solo in a song called “I Gotta Write This Down”  consists of two melodic lines. The lower melody is a descending scale I play in the pre-chorus.  And the upper melody is actually first species counterpoint against it.  That’s just a fancy way of saying independent melodies going note against note simultaneously creating some aural beauty.  Some JS Bach influence was at work for sure.

“Home Alone Blues’  – another tune from the same album – has some Beethoven-esque harmonies in the piano during the chorus. Moreover, there is some nice tremolo left hand figures in the opening riff, which I unconsciously borrowed from a Beethoven piano sonata I used to play as a kid. (I don’t think he would mind too much).

On our third album, “Rhyme and Treason,” there are a few songs which feature orchestral instruments.

In “After All This Time,” I placed a woodwind quartet (flute, oboe, clarinet, bassoon) performing a four part canon based on the piano melody in lieu of a guitar solo.

In the song “Getting By,” a viola doubles the guitar solo.

The guitar solos in “Too Sweet” also contains some violin like arpeggios.

“Tarantella” – an instrumental – could have easily been found in a Mozart type Theme and Variations composition as one of the variations.

But never mind all that technical ballyhoo.  What that all translates to is interesting and beautiful music to caress the ears and arouse the emotions.  After all, why do we listen to music at all?  Because it makes us feel. It satisfies something in us. It helps us connect with those feelings, those emotions, whatever they may be, wherever they may come from, wherever they go.

We write music for the same reason. We try tap into those things that moves us, that inspire us, that soothe us, that satisfy us … and in the process, we hope the music is able to connect with you, to satisfy you. If it does, then that’s Elm Treason’s raison d’etre.  That’s what it’s all about.



Posted in

Bobby Steel


  1. http://canadianorderpharmacy.com/ on June 4, 2019 at 7:05 am

    Please let me know if you’re looking for a article author for your blog. You have some really great articles and I feel I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d absolutely love to write some material for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please shoot me an e-mail if interested. Kudos!

    • Elm Treason on June 13, 2019 at 7:10 pm

      Please forgive the extended delay in getting back to you! Life has a way of intruding on our best laid plans sometimes. I’ll email you! Definitely. Thanks for the very kind words!

    • Elm Treason on June 13, 2019 at 7:42 pm

      HI! Andy here again. The email address you have on your profile does not work. The email I sent bounced back. If you email me at the band email address, and then give me your email address privately, I can get back to you.
      Email me at [email protected]


Leave a Comment