The Lennon I Admire

As of this writing, it’s been 39 years since John Lennon’s murder here in New York City. I remember that evening as vividly as anything in my life. I was a kid, born too late to be a first generation Beatlemaniac, with a dream of being either a professional musician or a radio personality, sitting in front of my television on that horrible night (when I certainly should have been in bed asleep) watching Monday Night Football as Howard Cosell made the chilling announcement on the air, somewhere around 11PM.

Lennon was dead.

As a youngster who had only recently become a bona-fide Beatlemaniac, his death was a tremendous blow. To the tens of millions of people he touched with his music, his senseless killing was as devastating a loss as there could have been outside of losing a loved one. That’s precisely how I felt at the time. I had no father growing up, so rock-n-roll – particularly the Beatles – were a kind of emotional salve. I so adored the music of the Beatles that – at the risk of sounding painfully maudlin – I felt like a little piece of me died that night.

Much has come and gone over three decades. Yet, as central to my life as music was (and still is) – as tightly as it is woven (you might say tangled) so completely throughout the fabric of my very existence – I grew to realize a cold hard reality that a fatherless boy in need of role models had to understand: that musicians were not infallible heroes. I don’t know of many entertainers who are, frankly. Whatever allusions I had as a young guy about the power and relevance of one’s celebrity was entirely a concoction of my own starving mind and soul that took almost everything I had to shake. It wasn’t easy, but I long ago stopped looking at celebrities as deities on earth – which was a huge thing for me – and chose to focus on their accomplishments.

Lennon himself would scoff at the idea of himself being a martyr or a hero of some kind. And as important as music is in every one of our lives – I’ve heard it appropriately referred to as “God’s drug” – I can hardly equate genuine heroism with a killer sounding rhythm guitar track (as in Lennon’s performance on the Beatles’ “All My Loving”). As a musician, I tremendously admire Lennon’s songwriting ability (particularly with the Beatles) and his capabilities as a rhythm guitarist.

Lennon, as the peace-loving, anti-establishment, power-to-the-people-politically-active variation of himself, is inexorably woven into the popular culture. Speaking purely as a musician, it is a genuine shame that when the name John Lennon is mentioned, the images that are first conjured up are almost always of his hippie-dippie, anti-war activist, bed-in era self, ever-epoxied to the side of Yoko Ono. (Please believe that I am not writing this from a political perspective whatsoever. Elm Treason does not talk politics on any of the band’s music sites…ever. We refuse to alienate half of our audience on matters that don’t concern the music). I use the word “shame” from a purely musical angle.

Lennon wrote outstanding music throughout the entire journey of his life, no question about that. But the fact is … that Jesus-Christ looking rock idol wouldn’t have become the “Imagine” crooning counter-cultural icon he did if it were not for what he and his three mates from Merseyside accomplished during the years 1963-1968.

It is John Lennon, the songwriter, the Beatle, the man who helped transform popular music forever (with his equally genius partner, Paul McCartney) that I acknowledge here – particularly the early Lennon material.

Simply put, John Lennon either wrote or co-wrote some of the most memorable music in the history of human civilization. His sense of melody, timing (odd as it could be at times) and his ability to create an unforgettable “hook” has rarely been duplicated – save for his partner of many years, Sir Paul McCartney. During the early Beatle years, so many of the songs that are now considered pop music standards and classics came from John Lennon.

Long before there was the experimental, socially conscious, primal scream version of John Lennon with wire-rims and scraggly center-parted hippie hair, there was the brilliant mop-topped songsmith John Lennon – the one that will forever have his name uttered by human lips long after almost every other human being that has ever existed on this planet is forever forgotten. The music and melodies he and Paul wrote were as influential on the artists that succeeded them as any that have ever existed. John, Paul, George and Ringo – to this day – are the benchmarks by which others are measured.

From the Beatles first number one song in Great Britain, “Please Please Me,” to the ahead-of-its-time guitar signatures on the infectious “I Feel Fine,” to the unforgettably heavy “Ticket To Ride,” to the melodic vulnerability and delicious harmonies of “Help!”, not to mention one of the most recognizable guitar riffs ever in “Day Tripper,” Lennon’s genius, coupled with his prolific output, is something to marvel at.

On the album “A Hard Day’s Night,” the first and only Beatles LP to contain nothing but Lennon-McCartney songs, 10 of the 13 songs were either composed partly by Lennon, or completely by him – including the instantly recognizable and beautiful “If I Fell,” the harmonica driven “I Should Have Known Better,” the Wilson Picket inspired “You Can’t Do That” and the rockin’ “Tell Me Why” – all radio staples.

Let’s not forget that he co-wrote, with Paul, some of the biggest hit singles in music history, including “I Want To Hold Your Hand,” “From Me To You,” “She Loves You” and “A Hard Day’s Night.”

1965 may have been his most amazing year of output. Along with aforementioned “Ticket To Ride,” “Help!” and “Day Tripper,” he composed such timeless classics as “Norwegian Wood,” “In My Life,” “Nowhere Man,” “Girl,” “You’ve Got To Hide Your Love Away” and “You’re Going To Lose That Girl.”

Damn impressive.

Equally extraordinary is his work on the “Revolver” LP from 1966, which was by that time becoming more complex and experimental – but no less memorable. “I’m Only Sleeping” is one of my favorite songs of all – lethargic, melodic, dreamy – and one of the most beautifully haunting melodies he ever composed. It is also, by the way, one of the first recordings ever (if not ever) to employ a completely backwards guitar solo. And yes, I adore the hypnotic “Tomorrow Never Knows” – a song that still sounds like it is not of this age, spawned from a distant and unknown future.

Two of his contributions to the “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band” LP are not only among his best ever, but are two of his most recognizable Beatle songs – “Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds” and “A Day In The Life” – both considered among the greatest classic rock tracks of all-time. (Yes, Paul composed the sensational middle section of the latter and came up with the naughty line “I’d love to turn you on.”) Addditionally, the brilliant “Strawberry Fields Forever,” is, too, from the same “Sgt. Pepper” sessions, but the track ultimately did not land on the album (rather, it was released as part of a double-A-sided single, paired with the equally magnificent “Penny Lane,” composed by Paul).

Indeed, I may not fully believe for a second that all we need is love, as he sang in the summer of 1967, but I still loved the song – particularly the line, “There’s nowhere you can be that isn’t where you’re meant to be.”

“I Am The Walrus” is one of my favorite recordings of all time, incidentally.

For my money, the genius Lennon – the one we should all be singing about around the campfire – is the Lennon I speak of, the one beyond the protests, the politics, the deified celebrity. I am enamored of the artist Lennon. And in my most humble (and dare I say controversial) opinion, save for the albums “Plastic Ono Band,” “Double Fantasy” and some of the tracks from “Imagine,” most of Lennon’s post-Beatle output is musically not up to snuff – but then again, look at who he is up against as a standard.

I’m just not interested in people’s activism, frankly. It doesn’t interest me in the least. Bumper sticker slogans and nifty catchphrases, regardless from where they emanate, rank just above “umbrella color” on my list of life’s relevant things to pay attention to. (Elm Treason has a song called “(Spoon Them) Dollops” touching upon this matter from the “Acoustic Treason” album).

But throw together some cool chords, a hook, a melody, the expression of an emotion intertwined through it all, a vibe, a groove, a feeling…..well, then you’ve got me for life. That’s the Lennon I admire.

Thus, I just wanted to take a moment – as a musician of many years myself – to say, from a musical perspective, “thank you” to Beatle John Lennon – a wonderful musician cut short in the prime of his life.

He was no savior. He was no hero. He was sometimes the walrus.

He was a hell of a songwriter.


Posted in

Andy Roman


  1. Bob Minter on November 7, 2018 at 1:20 am

    Wow. I guess somebody had to say it. Give me from the heart lyrics and the irresistible joy of the backbeat and I’m all in. Good piece.

    • Andy Roman on November 7, 2018 at 12:13 pm

      Hey Bob! Amen, brother. You wouldn’t think so, but the notion and power of Lennon’s early prowess as a songwriter seems to have been set aside, even if only a little bit, in favor of the “martyr” image that he himself would have despised. In the end, it’s only about the music….

      And yes, if it’s got a back beat that you can’t lose, I’m all in as well.

  2. Jaime Alexis Edades on January 7, 2019 at 5:38 pm

    Agreed! John Lennon is larger than life! I was a six year old chap who comes running each time our Philippine ZAMBOANGA local band practice on their yard! Whoa that was in 1963and their only way to cover BEATLES song was through a radio program The Voice of Australia ???????? yet the band sounded that good! I became “hooked” since then. I am past 60 now yet I enjoy my BEATLES on Smule!!!

    • Andy Roman on January 7, 2019 at 7:13 pm

      Hi Jaime! Appreciate your comments! How marvelous it must have been to experience the band when they were new and cutting edge! The memories must be exquisite! That’s something we will never know firsthand, sadly.

      Rock on!

  3. John on December 8, 2019 at 6:51 pm

    I could not disagree more. This article is 100% political despite your protests. Your opinion is a disgrace to Lennon’s life and legacy. To admire his music and dismiss his working-class, anti-war, pro-civil rights politics says a lot about you. I admire Lennon for risking his pop-star success, even his life, to promote peace and justice. He had courage while you promote disengagement from politics and therefore democracy. Shame on you.

    • Elm Treason on December 9, 2019 at 3:44 pm

      Hi John!

      Thanks for the comments. Truly appreciate you taking the time to read the blog and offering your insights and opinions.

      I must be honest… Before you posted your reply to this article, I had never thought of myself as a “disgrace” to John Lennon’s life and legacy. However, based on your rationale, it’s quite possible you are correct. Admittedly, I often can’t see the forest for my own trees.

      Additionally, I was not consciously aware that I was promoting disengagement – particularly in light of the fact that you have been kind enough to, in fact, engage with me here. I sincerely apologize if my presentation and tone did so. It certainly was not my intention.

      Wishing you well, John, with your music and your (hopefully) growing fan base. You’ve got some nifty riffs cooking!

      Rock on, brother!

    • Elm Treason on December 9, 2019 at 3:55 pm

      One other thing, John … Bobby and I invite you to come over to our always bustling, highly “engaged” ELM TREASON Facebook page. Bobby and I have a post linking to this blog, and your comments would be more than welcome there!

      • Bobby on December 9, 2019 at 11:48 pm

        Thank you for writing this piece. It’s a personal, unique take on Lennon seen filtered through your heart, mind and soul. I think it was done in a knowledgeable, intelligent, respectful and classy way. Sometimes it’s just good to get back to the basics and escape the political stuff if for a few moments ( since we are bombarded with it daily). It’s good to breathe and just enjoy John the composer. Focusing on one aspect doesn’t necessarily negate other aspects. But what an aspect to focus on! What a genius Lennon was and what an enormous loss to the musical community. Thank you for so eloquently reminding us of the things that truly feed the soul and make us human. Well done.

        • Elm Treason on December 10, 2019 at 12:11 am

          Thank you, Bobby. Your comment is truly appreciated.

          As long as we all continue making other plans, life is what will keep happening to us. And it is the music that permeates the fabric of that relentless life – and those gifted enough to bring us that music – that lives on!

  4. Mark Caro on June 22, 2020 at 2:42 am

    Well said. We’re from the same “Beatles Planet.”
    Thanks for articulating and writing what would’ve taken me months to write.
    Musically, Lennon was amazing in the Beatles.
    I was never impressed with his solo stuff, and , dare I say, the song “Imagine” ( in my opinion) is depressing.
    But his voice, at times, gives me goosebumps.

    • Andy Roman on June 23, 2020 at 6:32 pm

      Hi Mark!

      Thank you for the kind words. Indeed, the point of the article, which you clearly understand, is to pay tribute to the MUSICIAN and SONGWRITER, John Lennon. This isn’t to knock or deny or quibble with the other things he did in his life or the issues he stood up for, whether we agree with his positions or not. One can admire him – or not – for his political inclinations, if they so wish. But the purpose here was simply to say, “Hey, this is what made all of us know him – his music. And his track record in that department, particularly with the Beatles, has proven to transcend time, generation and personal political belief. Let’s talk about THAT.” In other words, let’s talk about that which would seem to unite us more than divide us – and that is his genius as a songwriter.

      And yes, there are moments when his voice DOES send chills down the spine.

      THANK YOU, Mark.


  5. NormanDub on August 25, 2020 at 12:50 am

Leave a Comment